FinTwit Audit: what their posted trades actually made

Every dollar figure on this site assumes a $1,000,000 account. Each trade is a % of that account (the size the trader posted, or the size a study models when none was posted), so +$100,000 means +10%.

What stood out

Tap one to open the full study

Scoreboard

Realized P&L on a $1M account, as each study sizes the trades

Trader	Source	Period	Closed trades	Win rate	Profit factor	P&L on $1M	No posted exit

Sizes differ by study (posted sizes, modeled risk, or real broker dollars), so the dollar column is not a like-for-like ranking. Each study explains its method and gaps.

The studies

A best-effort reconstruction, not an account statement. Each study is rebuilt from what the trader posted. Some trades may be missing, posted only in part, or read differently than he meant them. Some prices and sizes are estimated where the post left them out. The real account results can differ, in either direction. Each study lists its gaps and estimates. This is an independent study, not affiliated with the traders, and not investment advice.

All dollar figures assume a $1,000,000 account, with each trade sized as a % of that account. +$100,000 = +10%.

Realized equity, $1M account

Each point is a closed trade, booked on its exit date. No compounding.

P&L by month of exit

Blue = gain, red = loss. Hover for trade count.

Where the money came from

Top 10 and bottom 6 · ▼ = short book

Shape of the edge

Trades by price return, entry → exit

The short book

Short trades

Shorts are posted in their own ledger and paired the same way as longs.

Where the short record is incomplete:

All trades

· Press + on a row to see each fill.

Ticker

Ticker	Opened	Last action	Status	Size % acct	Avg entry	Avg exit	Return	P&L on $1M	Fills

How this was built

Source

Pricing

What to keep in mind

Sizes come from his own labels ("5%", "half size"); unlabeled buys default to 3–5%. "10% of what's left" and "10% of original" are treated alike.
Shorts with no price on both sides and futures hedges are left out. Open positions and trades never closed in the chat carry no P&L.
Fills priced from 15- or 30-minute bars (older alerts) add roughly ±0.3% noise per price.